★★★★☆ Its a small place with simple seating. But their pizza is really good . I had their chicken pizza with all the veges and pepperoni pizza Both were really good. Posted on June 29, 2014

★★★★★ Amazing!!! I have been here twice now. Had the pepperoni and the gyro and chicken. Amazing pizza my wife loved the gyro and chicken more I thought both were amazing. Great customer service which is rare now a days Posted on February 15, 2014

★★★★★ Always enjoy the Adam's Supreme Pizza they offer. Best pizza I have ever eaten! Posted on January 2, 2014

★★★★★ delicious, must try for sure. Posted on November 19, 2012

★★★☆☆ Although Eyman's Pizza is not superlative in Italian Standards, its edible pizza. I also admire the company providing boxes of pizzas for the local MSA at the University of Washington. Posted on September 8, 2011

★★★★★ this is the best halal pizza hands down fresh cooked pizza pie you cant lose I go again and again try for your self and you`ll see what I`M TALKING ABOUT. Posted on July 19, 2011

★★★★★ The best halal pizza in town. He has pepperoni topping, which of course is halal. When it comes pizza I don't pay from non halal because they use the same cutter they used other meat and you can only order veggie or cheese. But this place you don't worry those staff. Every thing is 100% halal and you can top with meat. He also offer gyro topping. Posted on April 19, 2011

★★★★★ Was in town for two days and came here both days. I had meat lovers pizza, pepperoni & chicken pizza and chicken terriyaki plate. All the items were excellent and fresh. The owner is very friendly and I would definitely recommend a visit to this establishment. Posted on February 2, 2011

★★★★★ Eyman’s bakes the best pizzas around. The selection is somewhat limited to the basics but he does offer a gyro topping and makes a great marinated chicken topping. Plus, he offers only rennetless cheeses. Last time I stopped in, he had burgers that were equally as tasty as his pizzas. Did I mention they keep a clean shop, too? If this place seems out of the way, don’t worry, it’s worth the trip. Posted on November 22, 2010

★★★★☆ Great take away place. The Pizza has more of a home made look feel and taste than the generic pizza places. The toppings are piled and the service is courteous. Price is equitable to the location. Always ask for their Specials :) Posted on November 14, 2010

★★★★★ My newest favorite place to eat. This place is Alhamdulillah run by a very courteous Muslim brother. He is still trying to build his menu but the Pizza here is out of this world. We had a take out order and we loved the pizza so much that we went back for a second the next day. I am impressed both with the brother's demeanor and his cooking skills. May Allah expand his business and bring him prosperity, happiness and success. Update 08/12/2010: I went there again about a month back and I have to say the previous 2-3 times I have noticed that the quality has gone down considerably. The owner wasn't there otherwise I would have relayed this to him personally. I think the fact that he wasn't there contributed to the low quality. Anyway, I don't think I will be going back there anytime soon. Posted on August 12, 2010

★★★★★ Small place, limited seating/decor.....but none of that matters 'cause the pizza is ridiculous . I really enjoyed the gyro pizza with roasted garlic and seasoned herbs. Great food and nice Muslim Brotha working there took care of us. Posted on August 1, 2010

★★★★★ They only serve pizza but the pizza was the best halal pizza I've had so far. Posted on July 25, 2010

★★☆☆☆ Visited Seattle 3 weeks ago and ate here because of good reviews. Restaurant area is not great, dining area is also poor and restroom was unusable. Food was average. Gyro pizza was good, chicken pizza was average and beef pizza was awful. I have no idea how this place can get so many 5/5's. Posted on April 17, 2010

★★★★★ This place is great. I spent 2 days in Seattle and ate here twice. The pizza is amazing, and reasonably priced considering how much meat is put on it. I recommend the gyro and pepperoni toppings. The brother there is very friendly and patient. The only thing I wish they had was sides like fries or onion rings, etc. It seems like they use to have sides, but now don't. Its still worth going to though, and I even took some pizza with me for my flight back home. Posted on April 13, 2010

★★★★★ Excellent pizza,must try the gyro topping and chicken topping is good too. This is pizza is good and trust me when i say this because im from ny. Posted on January 21, 2010

★★★★★ delicious! must try the gyro pizza. my favorite! Posted on January 18, 2010

★★★★★ Eyman's Pizza has the best pizza I have ever tasted, its fresh and custom made to however you like it. There are many selections to choose from which include toppings, pan sizes, and beverages. With their largest pizza costing less than $15, you can't go wrong. With the various sizes, one can have to option to eat as an afternoon snack or as a family dinner entree. I went to Seattle for 4 days and ate it everyday because I couldn't get enough of it. My family and I even took it to go on our 12 hour trip home. I would recommend Eyman's Pizza to anyone and everyone. Posted on August 19, 2009

★★★★★ The pizza is WONDERFUL! Full of Flavor, and there is NO skimping on the toppings.. what you Order, is What you Get! You won't be dissapointed inshAllah! The service is so genuine and prompt. It is the best pizza in WA Hands Down. BEST thing is, it is All Halal :) Posted on June 15, 2009

★★★★★ Everything is freshly prepared in a timely manner using only choice halal/kosher ingredients (beef pepperoni), for a price so low you almost feel guilty not paying more. The dine in environment is very clean, relaxing, and family friendly. This is truly some of the best pizza I've ever had! Posted on May 17, 2009

★★★★★ [No review submitted] Posted on May 11, 2009

★★★★★ Loved the pizza. Best I've had in Seattle. Better than Papa Johns or any of the other major pizza chains. Owner was very cordial and their service is excellent Posted on May 10, 2009

★★★★★ Excellent pizza (all toppings are halal) and the owner is friendly. Worth driving to! Posted on May 2, 2009

★★★★★ I'm a huge pizza fans. As a college student, we eat pizza almost every week. I have to say this is one of the best Independly own pizza joint I have tried. Taste, quality and presentation is way up. Posted on May 1, 2009

★★★★★ Definitely the best halal pizza in seattle area Posted on April 30, 2009

★★★★★ this was the best halal pizza i have ever had. usually the halal pizzas are not very good compared to a cheese pizza from papa Johns or dominos. But in this case the pizza is just as good or better, plus alhamdulillah, halal pepperoni, chicken and other toppings. The only downside, was they didn't have any Pho', wings or other sides; only pizza. the owner said by summer they will have it inshaAllah. Very friendly. Posted on March 14, 2009

★★★★★ Great pizza. 100% halal. Posted on March 8, 2009